10 Frequently Asked Questions I Get as a Mama

I get a lot of questions through social media on being a mama. So today I am going to share my answers to the most frequented asked Q’s about food, nursing and sleeping. 

Keep in mind there are many different opinions on the best way to do things – I’m sharing my own experiences as a mama based on what’s worked for us as a family.

I strongly encourage you to do your own research and have an open dialogue with your healthcare practitioner and most importantly, listen to your gut. I have been advised many things that I didn’t agree with like introducing rice cereal as Vienna’s first food. Does this mean if you gave your babe rice cereal they will suffer life-long consequences? Absolutely not. So please don’t stress! 

Here we go! Most frequently asked questions I get asked!


A photo posted by Joy McCarthy (@joyoushealth) on

Question 1: Do you recommend Baby Led Weaning (BLW)

My answer: I tried BLW with Vienna and I found the gagging too much for me to take! It didn’t feel right for us. I did my homework, did all the reading, watched extensive videos on how to do it effectively, learned all the benefits but at the end of the day, it didn’t work for us.

Instead, I started Vienna on purees and gradually just made them chunkier and then moved to finger foods. It was a very organic process. I didn’t just decide one day, okay now you only get finger foods. I let Vienna lead the way based on her readiness. And she still has purees because some days it’s the only way to get anything green into her body! You can read everything you need to know about Baby Food Introduction in this post. 

Question 2: Do I give Vienna gluten-containing foods and grains?

My answer: The short answer is yes, but the longer answer is not all the time and I’m picky with what she eats gluten and grain-wise.

Okay this is gonna be a long one… If Vienna had it her way, she’d probably live off French baguettes. Okay maybe I’m exaggerating a bit but she would never turn one down! Recently while dining at a nice restaurant after a long busy day in Vancouver, Vienna was a bit of a wild child – she was both tired and hungry and I was feeling the same way. Instead of duct taping her mouth, it was either play youtube songs for her on our iphone or let her have some of the house made bread that came to the table. We had no food in her diaper bag and so we opted for the bread, and her love of baguettes was born.

Don’t be mom shaming me now! Haha. No she doesn’t have white baguettes on the regular now. And no, I’m not worried or stressed about her eating gluten because 99% of what she eats is homemade, whole food. We have sprouted organic bread or sourdough pasta at home and this is what we give Vienna on occasion. She also has quinoa and oats, but grains and gluten are not a big part of her diet.

We don’t avoid gluten, but it’s also not something she has on a regular basis. In case you weren’t aware, gluten is the protein found in wheat, barley and rye. It’s also in many processed foods. The protein is pro-inflammatory and can cause digestive upset, it can cause eczema and it can impact your mood and this isn’t just in babies, adults too. Here’s the thing, gluten nowadays isn’t how our ancestors prepared it. Our ancestors fermented wheat to make it fit for our human digestive system.

I would rather Vienna be exposed to gluten and develop a tolerance for it. But again, I must stress that grains and gluten-containing foods shouldn’t be the main foods your children eat.  

As for grains, she has foods such a quinoa, millet, teff, buckwheat and while I realize not all of these are “grains” technically speaking, they fall under this category. The concern for many parents is that babies don’t produce enough amylase enzyme to properly break down the starches in grains. However, your baby’s saliva produces amylase and she also gets it in your breastmilk too. I’m not a fan of these alarmist approaches that treat grains like poison for your baby. If you’re feeding your baby French baguettes on the regular, then ya, that’s probably not a good idea. However, if you give your baby quinoa porridge once in a while or make cookies with oats and your baby or toddler digests them just fine with no negative symptoms then they are likely not sensitive to it.

As with any grain, it’s best if you soak it to reduce the phytic acid content. Phytates bind with minerals and may inhibit absorption in the digestive tract. So whenever I cook quinoa, I soak it before cooking it.

At the end of the day, just pay attention (I’m sure you do!) to your child’s reactions to foods.


Question 3: Was rice cereal Vienna’s first food?

My answer: No, this is advice I did not take from our paediatrician (and it wasn’t socks either…hehe). Doctors recommend rice cereal as a baby’s first food because it is fortified with iron. If your baby is exclusively breastfed the advice to give cereal as a first food is to ensure your child gets enough iron for growth because iron in breastmilk diminishes around six months. However, the iron in your breastmilk is still the most bioavailable iron your baby will ever get so even though the amounts are low, it’s still well absorbed.

While I’m not anti-rice-cereal, I just believe there are so many other more nutritious foods and alternatives to giving rice cereal every day. In the early days of food introduction, I gave Vienna foods like sweet potato, beets and squash as healthy sources of iron which also contain other vitamins and minerals for growth and development. I also don’t like the fact that rice does contain trace amounts of arsenic, so it doesn’t make sense to me to be giving this to a baby every day as a first food. But consider that apple juice, chicken and some protein powders can contain it as well. Unfortunately you can’t avoid absolutely every toxin and chemical your baby eats so this is why variety in your baby’s diet is absolutely essential.


Question 4: Do I give Vienna dairy and will I wean her from breast milk to cow’s milk?

My answer: I initially introduced dairy in the form of yogurt before 10 months because I wanted to increase her tolerance to allergenic foods (read more about other allergenic foods to introduce before a year here). I did this by giving her organic yogurt. She of course loved it – what’s not to love about a creamy and delicious substance? However, today, the only dairy she really has is organic goat milk when I’m not around to breastfeed, grass-fed cow’s milk yogurt on occasion or sheep’s milk yogurt or kefir in smoothies. Just like gluten, dairy does not have a huge presence in her diet. She does not have cow’s milk and this is not something we drink as a family.

Dairy is one of the most allergenic foods in North America. Additionally, most babies after weaning have significantly reduced lactase secretion — this is the enzyme that digests milk. I don’t want Vienna to develop a food sensitivity or an allergy to it so we keep it to a minimum, but just like gluten containing grains, we don’t completely avoid it. If your babe has any skin issues like eczema I would recommend taking a two week break from dairy.

I feel that goat milk is a better option and you can read more about the difference between cow and goat milk here. 

If you have any severe allergies to ANY food, it’s best to speak with your healthcare practitioner about introduction to your baby because it’s possible your child could have the same allergies.

Question 5: How much do I feed Vienna?

My answer: When Walker or I are feeding Vienna we try to be aware of her hunger cues. Now that she’s 14 months old she definitely let’s us know when she’s full and even if it seems she didn’t eat enough we don’t force feed her. She uses her hand to tell us “no”, I wish I had it on video because it’s pretty funny! We don’t do the airplane motion to force feed her because I believe when she motions “no more” she means it.

Also, sometimes she just needs a break. When we are out at a restaurant we always bring books with us to keep her occupied (not baguettes or youtube haha!). I really find this to be helpful — giving her a break that is. Like this morning, I gave her a smoothie and after like 5 sips she needed a break. So we chatted a bit, she had some Love Child’s granola bar and then we continued with the smoothie. Check out Vienna’s smoothie and favourite foods in this post!

Vienna's Favourite Foods

Of course there are days that I feel like she has eaten nothing but sure enough the next day or the next meal she will make up for it. I recently heard someone say, don’t worry about how much they eat in a day, notice how much they eat over the course of a week. I don’t stress out about how much she eats in a day as long as she’s gaining weight at a healthy rate, peeing and pooping and an overall happy little camper.

Again, I must stress that I think it’s important not to force feed children. Babies build their confidence and understanding of their own hunger cues when you allow them to make the decision of their hunger and fullness.

Before I move on to the next question, you’re probably wondering if you’ve just introduced food to your baby, how much will they eat? Again, pay attention to their cues. Most babies will eat about a tsp or tbsp. of food in the first few weeks of food intro. Just think about how strange this to them! Also keep in mind their stomachs are still super small!

Do remember that from birth to 12 months, breastmilk or formula should be the majority of what your baby eats.

Food is complementary to milk. I started giving Vienna 3 meals a day when she was around 9/10 months. But her overall caloric consumption was mainly breastmilk.

Question 6: Do I feed Vienna at the same time every day?

My answer: For the most part yes, we try to be consistent with meal times but it doesn’t always work out as planned. For example, if she’s up at 7 and has breakfast at 7:45am and goes down for a nap at 9:30, sleeps for an hour and I give her a snack at 11am she might not be ready for a full lunch meal for 12 noon. If she doesn’t have a morning nap because I think she’s gonna drop the a.m. nap soon then I will give her lunch a little earlier. Whenever we go out or go for long walks I bring snacks for her. Here are some of the snacks she loves.

Every mama has a different method and routine with naps and meals. Walker and I are a little more flexible in this regard, but if sticking to a strict routine is what works for your family then keep doing that.

Question 7: What do you give a baby for healthy fats when they turn one?

My answer: Great question. Fat is very important for brain development, weight gain and blood sugar balance. Our favourite fats for Vienna beyond breastmilk because that’s the most important fat she gets, are eggs (mDeviled Eggs-2ake sure to include the yolk), avocado, olives, goat or coconut yogurt, coconut butter (in smoothies), nut butters and coconut milk or goat milk.

Question 8: When did you start sleep training?

My answer: At around six months we started to get Vienna on more of a schedule sleep-wise. We tried earlier but failed so we decided to wait. However, she was always in bed by 7pm at the latest since around 7 or 8 weeks. She’s fell into a routine pretty quick. I don’t know if that’s more personality-based or our training. We always made sure she had a really good meal before bed which was usually breastmilk and she slept through the night unless she was teething or has a cold. And that’s the same story at 14 months. She goes to bed between 6:30 and 7pm and sleeps until 6:30 or 7am.

There were definitely some naps and nights that she wasn’t happy about being put in the crib. We had to resort to letting her cry for 5 minutes at a time before we went in and soothed her. If however, it was a blood-curdling cry we never let her cry for 5 minutes. But if she’s teething or has a cold we don’t let her cry at all.

Question 9: What supplements do you give Vienna?

My answer:

Vitamin D: Since birth I’ve been giving Vienna vitamin D. D is important for your baby to develop strong bones and teeth and a healthy strong immune system. It is also critical to the heart and nervous system. If you supplement with around 5000 IUs of vitamin D per day (meaning, YOU take this much) and you breastfeed this will be adequate. If your baby is formula fed, they should be getting vitamin D from their formula. Breastfed infants should receive around 400 IUs per day so if you’re not taking it yourself, then give your baby vitamin D.

I use Natural Factors Vitamin D for babies. I like the dropper. It’s super easy to drop it into her mouth.

Probiotics: I also give Vienna probiotics daily and I’ve been doing that since birth. Probiotics contribute to a healthy digestive system and digestion is the foundation of great health. It contributes to a healthy immune system, aids in absorption of nutrients, reduces inflammation, prevents diarrhea and constipation and reduces the risk of skin problems like eczema.

I give her Genestra’s Natogen or Progressive’s Baby Probiotics. I mix it with a touch of water and put it on a spoon or mix it in a smoothie. You could also mix it into formula, same with vitamin D.  

DHA: When she turned one we started supplementing with DHA. Babies main source of DHA is from breastmilk or formula. However, I really do not think the DHA in formula is going to be as good as from breastmilk unfortunately.  I give Vienna a supplement now because she doesn’t breastfeed as much as she did when she was 6 months old. DHA is super important for brain development.

We give her Nordic Natural’s Baby DHA and I mix it into a smoothie or porridge cause it tastes gross.

Question 10: How many months am I going to breastfeed for?

I love Dr. Sears answer to this question. The question should be, how many years are you going breastfeed for? My plan is to breastfeed until Vienna is 2 years old – then we will see! She currently nurses about 4-6 times a day. When I have a sitter during the day, then it’s more like 3 times per day. If she’s sick or teething then it’s 6x per day.

The immune boosting benefits of breastmilk from birth to 24 months should not be ignored! So if you can breastfeed continue as long as you can. 

Since I’ve only answered 10 of 104 comments I received on social media I have decided to do a facebook LIVE Q&A on Thursday November 24th at 12pm EST / 9am PST to answer more questions. Don’t worry if you can’t attend live, you can watch the replay and I will post it here once it’s done.

Thank you for taking the time to ask your question through social media. Sorry if I didn’t answer it here. I was a bit overwhelmed with the number of questions!!

Have a joyous week and I wish you and your little one joyous health!


Ps. I apologize if this post has grammar and spelling errors. It’s been kinda crazy busy lately and it took me a really long time to write this as you can tell I’m at almost 2500 words!   


Joy McCarthy

Joy McCarthy is the vibrant Holistic Nutritionist behind Joyous Health. Author of JOYOUS HEALTH: Eat & Live Well without Dieting, professional speaker, nutrition expert on Global’s Morning Show, Faculty Member at Institute of Holistic Nutrition and co-creator of Eat Well Feel Well. Read more...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

  • I’m glad you talked about the baby led weaning (I asked that one, hehe). I originally thought the idea sounded fantastic, and then I read the book and to be honest I kind of lost respect for them when they said pizza and cake are okay to give sometimes…I mean for a 6 month old?! Anyways, thanks for answering all the q’s, it was cool to get a snippet of how you do your thing with your babe.

    • Thanks for the awesome question, Tijana! I hope you found the post helpful :)
      Heather- Joyous Health Team

    • My pleasure! Oh my goodness I didn’t know the BLW book recommended that for 6-month olds, that’s kinda crazy! Glad you enjoyed my post. Sofrry for the delay in responding I somehow missed this comment!

  • This was great. I love reading how different people bring up their children. It’s very interesting to read different perspectives.
    You are lucky Vienna just puts her hand up when she’s full. My daughter just starts throwing her food on the floor to signify she is done. Lucky we have a dog for easier clean ups!

    • Oh Vienna does that too! :) She went through a period of about 8 weeks doing that. We have hit a good streak!! Thank goodness for dogs!

  • This is such a great post! I was wondering if you could provide a direct link to the probiotics that you use? I’m having trouble locating the exact ones you mentioned. Many thanks!

  • Great post! I’m due in 3 months with my first baby and I’m sure I’ll refer back to this. After you’re done breast feeding at 24 months will you replace that with more milk or just more of all the healthy foods you’ve been giving her?

    • Hey Jessica!

      Joy will be continuing by feeding her more of the healthy foods she’s been giving her :)

      Rachel – Joyous Health Team